Zoocasa
Sold Prices
Map
Market Insights
  • Blog Home
  • For Buyers
  • For Sellers
  • Real Estate News
  • Mortgage News in Canada
  • Free Guides (PDF)
  • Real Estate Infographics
Zoocasa
  • Blog Home
  • For Buyers
  • For Sellers
  • Real Estate News
  • Mortgage News in Canada
  • Free Guides (PDF)
  • Real Estate Infographics
Home Affordability

Data Shows Housing Affordability Is Up, So Why Aren’t Americans Feeling It?

Grace Dickens by Grace Dickens
November 18, 2026
in Affordability, Affordability Reports, Buying a Home, First Time Home Buyer, Home Featured, United States, US
Reading Time: 8 mins read
home affordability
Share
Tweet
Share
0 Shares

For many aspiring homebuyers, landing the keys to a first home is the ultimate goal. But recently, a strange gap has opened up between what economic reports say and what everyday Americans actually experience.

A report from the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) found that housing affordability has technically improved from its historical lows, holding above its baseline benchmark into late 2026. Yet across the country, buyers are still feeling spent. 

Zoocasa analyzed recent NAR data alongside consumer debt reports, inflation indices, and mortgage monitoring data to uncover why.

Here’s what we found: While official formulas show qualifying incomes have nominally caught up with home costs, mounting household debt, sharp regional splits, day-to-day living expenses, and overlooked ownership bills have wiped out any theoretical relief. 

“When you look strictly at the headline affordability index, it suggests buyers have more breathing room than they did during peak pressure points, but affordability doesn’t exist in a vacuum,” Zoocasa Industry Relations Officer Brittany Kostov said. “Families don’t pay their mortgage with theoretical income. It comes out of a paycheck that is getting squeezed by everyday essentials, higher credit balances, and jumps in property taxes and home insurance. On paper, affordability is higher, but real-life purchasing power remains as tight as ever.”

Defining Housing Affordability

The NAR’s Housing Affordability Index (HAI) tracks whether a family earning the median income makes enough to qualify for an 80% conventional mortgage on a typical home.

In 2023 and 2024, the HAI was deeply depressed at 96.9 and 97.9. In the years since, the index hit 106.7 in Sept. 2025, and was still at 105.4 as of Sept. 2026. While that figure represents a slight pullback from the prior autumn, it remains well above the sub-100 marks that defined the post-pandemic mortgage rate shock.

  • Read: Houses for Sale Under $100K: Where Can You Still Find Affordable Homes in the U.S.?

Zooming in shows why this improvement feels hollow to buyers. Between Sept. 2025 and Sept. 2026, the median home price climbed from $417,600 to $422,700, while mortgage rates increased from 6.43% to 6.94%. The typical monthly principal and interest (P&I) payment also rose by $140, jumping from $2,096 to $2,236. 

The reason the HAI remained above 100 is that modeled median family income rose enough on paper to bring the estimated payment-to-income share down to 23.7%. But that calculation assumes household income is unencumbered by other debt–an assumption that clashes directly with consumer realities.

Affordability Gains Stop at the Coastlines

National averages can mask the localized realities of economic conditions. When broken down by region, housing affordability shows a stark contrast: high living costs remain concentrated along the coasts, while the Midwest carries the weight of national accessibility.

Over the past year, affordability conditions worsened across three of the country’s four regions. The gap widened the most in the Northeast with a 4.3 drop in the HAI, bringing an already low HAI of 95.8 down to 95.1. The Midwest remains the nation’s most affordable region, though its index still drifted down from 133.9 to 129.7. Additionally, affordability in the South slipped from 113.1 to 112.7. 

The West represents the most severe outlier. While its index moved marginally from 77.1 to 77.9, the region remains locked away from median earners. Purchasing a median-priced home of $623,700 requires a monthly P&I check of $3,300, which consumes nearly a third of median income before factoring in property taxes or insurance. 

For buyers in these high-cost states, national index gains mean very little when regional numbers are far underwater.

Wage Gains Swallowed by Rising Payments

The standard housing index models an idealized scenario where a household dedicates roughly 24% to 25% of gross earnings strictly to housing. In real life, most households carry substantial competing debt.

Federal Reserve data show a nationwide acceleration in household debt between late 2024 and late 2025, based on debt-to-income ratios. Broad consumer credit reports show credit card balances, auto loans, and personal financing have climbed over the past 24 months, restricting how much income buyers can put toward a mortgage.

When total debt obligations are factored in, qualifying costs continue to outpace family earnings. Between Aug. 2025 and Aug. 2026, median household income grew by 2.4%. Meanwhile, median home prices rose 2.7%, interest rates increased from 6.6% to 6.7%, and base monthly P&I payments increased by 3.6%. 

  • Read: 10 U.S. Metros Where Home Prices Are Falling Fastest

Total monthly mortgage costs–which bundle principal, interest, taxes, homeowners insurance, and private mortgage insurance–expanded by 3.5%, rising from $3,065 to $3,172 per month. 

Because total monthly housing bills grew faster than median earnings, any pay gains were effectively absorbed by debt service before buyers could set aside savings for a home.

First-Time Buyers Face an Uphill Battle

Hidden beneath the national numbers for overall home affordability is the plight of the first-time buyer. While gains have increased since 2023, there has been increasing volatility in the HAI, which was down to 68.9 in Q3 2026. 

The HAI has also historically been much lower for first-time buyers compared to the national average, with the HAI for first-time buyers at 67.9 in 2025, compared to 102.5 for all buyers. 

A score of 68.9 in Q3 means a typical first-time buyer earns less than 70% of the income needed to qualify for a starter home. For qualifying income in Q3 2026, this creates an income gap of nearly $33,000. Overall, the data shows entry-level buyers are confronting a barrier that broader national averages aren’t able to capture. 

Everyday Costs and Escrow Expenses Squeeze Budgets

Beyond mortgage qualification metrics, everyday expenses have kept household balance sheets tight.

Data measuring price changes between Sept. 2025 and Sept. 2026 show massive swings in household essential costs, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. For instance, while the cost of eggs went down 34.86% over the last year, the cost of energy surged almost just as much. Larger household costs like electricity and natural gas per unit increased 4.26% and 5.39%, respectively, likely meaning an overall heavier weight on household budgets. 

  • Read: How Mortgage Rates Impact Homeownership in the U.S.

When transportation and heating bills jump by those margins, the disposable income needed to save for closing costs or a down payment disappears quickly.

At the same time, ownership costs beyond the mortgage itself are rising rapidly, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta. Property insurance jumped 4.8% from Aug. 2025 to Aug. 2026, while property taxes rose 2.9% and PMI edged up 3.0%. Combined, these non-mortgage fees now add $822 per month to the baseline loan payment.

These hidden escrow expenses may help explain much of why buyers feel financially burdened, even when affordability is technically better than it was a few years ago.

What The Latest Affordability Figures Mean for Homebuyers

While NAR’s data accurately reflects that mathematical affordability is better than it was during recent record lows, they’re not the whole story.

Between surging property insurance, higher local taxes, elevated utility bills, consumer debt burdens, and a starter home gap of nearly $33,000 for first-time buyers, it makes sense that everyday buyers are not feeling the improvement.

If you’re looking to buy a home today, evaluating listing price and interest rate isn’t enough. Taking the time to price out localized property taxes, obtain real insurance quotes, and factor in personal monthly liabilities is the best way to ensure your purchase makes financial sense over the long haul.

Figuring out what you can realistically afford is a big undertaking, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. Zoocasa has agents across the country who can help you map out the true cost of buying a home. Reach out today.

Methodology

Housing affordability metrics, regional indexes, and first-time buyer datasets were pulled from National Association of REALTORS® Sept. 2026 affordability reports. County-level debt trends and consumer liability metrics were sourced from Federal Reserve reports. Total monthly mortgage payment components were compiled from the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta’s Home Ownership Affordability Monitor. Consumer price changes for grocery items, gasoline, and utilities were sourced from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index reports from Sept. 2025 through Sept. 2026.

Previous Post

Canadian Home Sales Down 10.6% Year Over Year in October: CREA

Next Post

Cities With the Most Young Homeowners (Under 35) in the U.S. and Why They’re Attracting Buyers

Grace Dickens

Grace Dickens

Grace Dickens is a Public Relations & Content Marketing Specialist at Zoocasa. As a Texas native, she’s spent years understanding the ins and outs of major cities to keep a pulse on what drives local real estate markets. With a background in visualization, Grace uses data-driven insights to shed light on what’s happening in housing markets across the United States to keep buyers, sellers and agents informed about their communities.

Related Posts

duplex home
Advice

Can You Live in One Side of a Duplex and Rent Out the Other?

November 20, 2026
home being constructed
Advice

The Pros and Cons of Buying a Pre-Construction Home in Canada

November 20, 2026
Buying a Home

Cities With the Most Young Homeowners (Under 35) in the U.S. and Why They’re Attracting Buyers

November 19, 2026

Blog Search

No Result
View All Result

Newsletter Sign-up

Join a community of 130,000+ subscribers. Don't miss important real estate news, market data, and buying and selling tips.

Recent Articles

duplex home

Can You Live in One Side of a Duplex and Rent Out the Other?

November 20, 2026
home being constructed

The Pros and Cons of Buying a Pre-Construction Home in Canada

November 20, 2026

Cities With the Most Young Homeowners (Under 35) in the U.S. and Why They’re Attracting Buyers

November 19, 2026
home affordability

Data Shows Housing Affordability Is Up, So Why Aren’t Americans Feeling It?

November 18, 2026

Featured Listings

House with land from sky view

Homes for Sale With Land in the U.S.

November 15, 2026
Toronto downtown with shops and condos

Updated: 7 Houses Currently For Sale in Toronto Under $699,999

October 6, 2026
Enchanted forest scene with a tiny moss-covered stone cottage, glowing doorway, giant trees, mushrooms, and a rustic wooden bridge, evoking quiet wonder.

6 Unique Homes in the US With Features You Won’t Find in a Typical Listing

August 25, 2026

You’d Never Guess These Were Churches: 5 Canadian Homes With Remarkable Histories

August 13, 2026
first-time home buyer programs and rebates

Social Media

250 The Esplanade Suite 408 Toronto, ON M5A 4J5

Stay Connected

  • Blog Home
  • For Buyers
  • For Sellers
  • Real Estate News
  • Mortgage News in Canada
  • Free Guides (PDF)
  • Real Estate Infographics
No Result
View All Result

Zoocasa © 2007–2022. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.