Map
Listed price in listed location currency (USD).
$1,500,000

530

MLS® 1004894

Open House
Sat May 30, 4:00-6:00 PM UTCSun Jun 7, 4:00-6:00 PM UTCThu May 28, 5:00-7:00 PM UTCSun May 31, 4:00-6:00 PM UTCSat Jun 6, 4:00-6:00 PM UTC

Overview

Key Facts

Type Single Family Residence
Levels Residential
Size 2845 sqft
Garage 
Taxes $7,153
Days Active 0
Lot Size 
Approx. Age 1880
Avg. Price Per Sqft $527
MLS® Number 1004894

Property Address: 5 Spring Garden Ave, Shelter Is Ht, NY, 11965

Average square foot calculated using Size range provided by listing agent.

Description

Dating back to the original 1871 layout of the Shelter Island Grove and Camp Meeting Association, Spring Garden Avenue is celebrated for its organic, rolling streetscapes and preserved 19th-century architecture. 5 Spring Garden Avenue is an authentic 1880 Victorian residence that embodies the classic style of the era, from its steeply pitched rooflines to its expansive exterior woodwork. The interior layout is expansive and true to its vintage, characterized by distinctive octagonal rooms on both the first and second floors. With five bedrooms, a sprawling third-floor attic loft, and a substantial footprint of covered decks and porches, the home offers a generous canvas within a historic setting. A significant structural update was completed in 2008, replacing the older foundation with a new poured concrete basement and structural footings, alongside the installation of a new roof. Featuring full access to the Shelter Island Heights Association tennis courts and beach club, this property represents an authentic piece of island history.
MLS® Number1004894
Laundry Level
Central VacNo
FireplaceYes
Acreage
Exterior
Garage
Approx. Age1880
BasementBilco Door(s), Full, Storage Space, Unfinished, Walk-Out Access
DrivewayDriveway
Garage Spaces
Heat
A/C
Heating Fuel

Extras

Price History

-End Date
Not Sold YetSold Price

For Sale

May 27, 2026List Date
$1,500,000List Price

Map

Like what you see?

Complete the form and we'll be in touch. No login necessary.

Add a Comment
Loading...

Similar Listings

Comparable Properties